| 2009 |
Liz Seibel, Penn State |
| 2008 |
Ashly Galante, Pikeville |
| 2007 |
Jamie Foster, Pikeville |
| 2006 |
Kerry Smith, Shippensburg |
| 2005 |
Kayla Bandy, Pikeville |
| 2004 |
Elysia Current, Fairleigh Dickinson |
| 2003 |
Tina Stickney, West Texas A&M |
| 2002 |
Emily Hampson, West Texas A&M |
| 2001 |
Shannon Pluhowsky, Nebraska |
| 2000 |
Kristal Scott, Wichita State |
| 1999 |
Stacey Bokina, Briarcliffe |
| 1998 |
Robin Crawford, Morehead State |
| 1997 |
Tammy Schmidt, Erie CC |
| 1996 |
Keli Rapp, Erie CC |
| 1995 |
Erin McDonnell, Central Missouri State |
| 1994 |
Jody Ellis, Erie CC |
| 1993 |
Liz Johnson, Morehead State |
| 1992 |
Laurie Ross, Florida |
| 1991 |
Sandy Youker, Erie CC |
| 1990 |
Kim Wong, Fresno State |
| 1989 |
Kim Berke, Nebraska |
| 1988 |
Dionne Lee, San Jose State |
| Men |
| 2011 |
Charles Easton, Toledo |
| 2010 |
Mark Scuderi, Rochester Institute of Technology |
| 2009 |
Larry Brande ,Webber International |
| 2008 |
Chris Bardol, Robert Morris (Ill.) |
| 2007 |
Matt O'Grady, William Paterson |
| 2006 |
Ronnie Sparks Jr., Pikeville |
| 2005 |
Ryan Ciminelli, Erie CC |
| 2004 |
Brian Valenta, Lindenwood |
| 2003 |
T.J. Mento, Mohawk Valley CC |
| 2002 |
Jeff Butler, Michigan State |
| 2001 |
Scott Norton, Cal State-Fullerton |
| 2000 |
Mike Remaklus, Central Missouri State |
| 1999 |
Eddie Kirtley, Arizona State |
| 1998 |
John Asbaty, William Paterson |
| 1997 |
Brian Waliczek, Saginaw Valley State |
| 1996 |
Ryan Kretchmer, Nebraska |
| 1995 |
Jeff Hartsfield, West Texas A&M |
| 1994 |
Joe Ciccone, Erie CC |
| 1993 |
Bill Hoffman, Ohio State |
| 1992 |
Jon Murph, Morehead State |
| 1991 |
David Garber, Wichita State |
| 1990 |
Dave Carter, William Paterson |
| 1989 |
Chris Sole, William Paterson |
| 1988 |
Chris Viale, William Paterson |